Common Mistakes First-Time Fund Managers Make (And How to Avoid Them)

Moving into a first-time fund management position is akin to crossing an invisible line. It means moving from a role advising founders to one that does not necessarily involve direct fund management responsibilities.

It's an exciting position, but it also marks the point at which fund managers on the rise often encounter challenges. It's not because they lack intelligence or good intentions, but because fund management can be much more complex than it appears at first glance.

Most new fund managers make elementary errors that are easily avoidable. Here’s a list of them: 

‍

‍

Common Mistakes First-Time Fund Managers Make 

1. Raising a Fund Before Earning Investor Trust

One of the biggest mistakes first-time fund managers make is launching a fund without first building investor trust. Many first-time managers often give the impression that trust follows capital, but it does not.

That’s precisely why limited partners invest in more than just deal flow—it is your judgment, discipline, and decision-making.

The significant challenges in this phase:

• Lack of a verifiable track record of capital deployment. 
• Answering LP questions with hypothetical scenarios instead of hard facts.
• Managers struggle to explain how they manage downside risk and failures.

Trust is built by demonstrating how you think, act, and communicate under conditions of uncertainty. Those emerging managers who ignore this often have to wait longer to raise funds and may lack firm conviction from their LPs.

2. Confusing Good Deals with a Real Investment Strategy

Another common mistake is mistaking access to good bargains for a strategy. It is common for novice fund managers to aspire to invest in promising founders or promising startups, but this is not a strategy.

It must be a sound investment strategy that provides a framework for making investment decisions in emotionally charged or noisy markets.

A strategy should specify the following:

• The stages in which you invest
• Typical check sizes
• Industries or themes you pursue or avoid
• Risk appetite and ownership targets

In the absence of such guardrails, managers end up acting reactively. This lack of clarity makes it difficult for LPs to understand what they are investing in and why your fund should be part of their portfolios.

3. Legal and Compliance Complexity Underestimation

New fund managers often underestimate the scope of fund management beyond choosing which startups to fund. The organizational, regulatory, paperwork, and reporting associated with fund management are essential to running a fund.

Most new managers assume they can address these concerns later.

Common pitfalls include:

• Delaying regulatory filings
• Poorly structured fund documents
• Inconsistent reporting standards
• Weak understanding of fiduciary responsibility

Issues related to a business's legal and compliance matters are not only time- and resource-consuming; they also create stress and divert focus from investing. It will play an essential role in a fund's stable operation to understand these obligations at an earlier stage.

4. Overestimating the Ease of Raising Capital

Launching the first fund rarely proves as seamless as one expects. Some top-connected fund managers may be surprised by the measured pace of LP decision-making.

Money does not flow as quickly as one would like, even with a fund launch.

These may include:

• Long fundraising cycles
• Inconsistent LP follow-up
• Lack of momentum in fundraising

This phase can be emotionally draining. The managers can experience loss of faith, loss of confidence, and frustration. Unprepared managers can get discouraged very easily during this phase.

5. Skipping Syndicates and Launching a Fund Too Early

One of the most practical early mistakes is skipping syndication and moving directly to fund structuring. Syndicates can be a better way to start investing because they involve less legal complexity.

Starting with syndicates helps you:

• Establishing an observable public record
• Learning Deal Sourcing and Evaluation
• Practice investor communication
• Obtaining hands-on experience with the use of capital

Syndicates serve as a learning ground for investment managers, allowing them to gain experience without the pressure of overseeing a large investment fund. Investors become receptive to investment managers who have proven themselves consistent through their participation in investment syndicates.

For those seeking a more structured approach, Angel School’s Syndicate Blueprint program is there to help you. This program allows angels to structure their syndicates, raise deal-by-deal capital, and manage investor expectations, among other tasks, in preparation for a fundraise.

Instead of an expensive trial-and-error process, the angels gain clarity through this process.

6. Treating LP Communication as an Afterthought

First-time fund managers often overfocus on transactions and underestimate the importance of communication with LPs. It’s the wrong strategy.

LPs do not expect flawless performance; however, they do require transparency. Silence creates concern, especially when startups are experiencing tough times.

Successful LP communication involves:

• Regular and Predictable Updates
• Complete reporting of success and failure instances
• Clear context of investing decisions

Effective communication builds trust, even in the face of uncertainty. Lack of communication erodes trust, no matter how well things are performing. Fund management is not just about performance; it is also about maintaining strong, transparent relationships.

7. Poor Portfolio Construction and Over-Concentration

Another area where new managers often go wrong is portfolio management. Being overly passionate about a set of startups can lead to over-concentration.

Investing a large amount of money in a few companies drastically increases the risk.

Effective portfolio management needs:

• Diversification in industries & stages
• Informed position sizing
• Awareness of correlation risk

Although the mathematics of portfolio investment may not hold much glamour, its impact is quite considerable in the long run. Creating a portfolio offers several advantages: it reduces risk by diversifying across assets, and it provides a more stable return on investment.

8. Overlooking the Power Law in Venture Exits

One mistake young fund managers often make is ignoring the power-law effect. Venture returns do not follow a normal distribution; outliers drive the most significant gains.

New fund managers tend to invest capital too evenly or be reluctant to double down on an idea or portfolio.

The presence of the power law distribution shapes the following:

• Follow-on investment decisions
• Reserve allocation
• Conviction-based investing

Ignoring this process leads to diluted outcomes. It is essential to recognize it early to enable the formulation of portfolios capable of delivering venture-scale results. A small number of exits typically return the entire fund, which LPs already expect.

9. Being a Jack-of-All-Trades

First-time fund managers also face pressure to say yes to deals, trends, and advice from all corners. A lack of focus hurts decision-making and weakens strategy.

Attention is sharpened by:

• Set investment boundaries clearly
• Just say no.
• Don’t chase hype cycles.

Good investment managers are selective. They understand the importance of the word "no" to protect time and money.

10. Undervaluing the Time & Effort Involved

Managing funds is not a sideline. Smaller funds also require sustained attention. Exits are taking longer than expected, and no one is immune to setbacks.

First-time managers often underestimate:

• The psychological burden of long timelines
• The ongoing workload beyond deal execution
• The patience required for returns

The best way to avoid burnout or regrets in the future is to be upfront about the commitment before launching a fund.

11. Lack of Operational Discipline

First-time fund managers often treat operations as secondary, which can be very risky. These aspects are vital for credibility and efficiency purposes.

Operational discipline encompasses:

• Record keeping.
• Clear documentation processes
• Financial Reporting System:

Effective operational management is an indicator of professionalism, while poor operational management causes a lack of clarity among investors and results in their loss of trust

12. Learning the Hard Way About Everything

Many new emerging fund managers feel that struggle and credibility are the same thing. Learning from experienced professionals shortens the learning curve and reduces unnecessary errors.

The most prudent manager seeks structure, learning, and practical frameworks.

Support for learning helps with:

• Understanding fund mechanics
• Minimizing legal and operating blunders
• Building confidence in decision-making

The Syndicate Blueprint program by Angel School serves this purpose, especially for first-time managers entering new territory.

13. Misunderstanding Fund Economics and Incentive Alignment

Most new fund managers focus intensely on raising capital and selecting startups, but they often overlook the economics of running a fund. It is an area that causes friction in the long term.

Economics in a fund are more about alignment, rather than just management fees and carried interest. If the rewards system is weak, it distorts decision-making, regardless of how strong the motive.

Emerging fund managers tend to underestimate the costs management fees must defray. Legal bills, regulatory costs, accountants, reporting software, data access fees, and staff assistance add up.

LPs worry that inadequate management fees may require the manager to supplement out of pocket, leading to exhaustion and a lack of focus. LPs may also be concerned about economic factors they do not fully understand, particularly the manager’s incentive structure.

The following mistakes occur most frequently in fund economics:

• Fixing fees without regard to long-run production costs
• Misalignment of Carry Structures and Value Creation
• Not articulating incentives to LPs clearly up front

Good fund economics gives you clarity. It allows GPs to focus on sound investment decisions rather than on sustainability, and offers investors confidence that they are dealing with professionals.

LPs will gain greater confidence once they understand why compensation is structured as it is.

New GPs who choose to learn about fund economics have a good chance of building long-term platforms rather than short-term funds driven by short-term pressures.

14. Creating a Fund Without Investing in Team and Support Systems

Another overlooked management error is the inability to function effectively without help from others.

While this may feel necessary at the outset, it often becomes an impediment over time. You cannot manage funds alone. That’s why many young managers delay establishing their support structures, as they feel they may be dispensable.

In truth, the absence of adequate support infrastructure can slow decision-making and increase the risk of errors. Even with limited financial resources, sound legal counsel, accounting support, and operational assistance will be available.

Problems are likely to arise when there is a lack of support

• Missed follow-ups with founders and/or LPs
• Inconsistent data tracking and reporting
• Increased cognitive workload and decision fatigue

Team building does not mean immediately setting up staff. It means designing scalable operations that may or may not include outsourcing.

Having effective support operations means freeing up mental cycles, allowing fund managers to focus on judgmental, relational, and strategic thinking rather than operational pressure.

‍

‍

Early-stage fund managers who start on the right investment path are much clearer about how to execute. They make fewer unnecessary errors, which in turn helps them come off as institutional-standard fund managers even when managing smaller investment funds.

Conclusion: Build Before You Scale

Many errors by first-time investment managers stem from rushing the process. Launching too soon creates pressure when managers bypass necessary steps and underestimate the complexity of fund management. The investment management business is a setting where the principles of patience, clarity, and discipline apply. The most successful up-and-coming fund managers first gain experience before expanding.

Syndicates offer a more straightforward, lower-risk way to learn to deploy capital, manage investors, and hone investment acumen on a deal-by-deal basis. They are a good way to gain credibility before soliciting LPs for a blind pool commitment.

For those seeking a structured starting point, Angel School’s Syndicate Blueprint helps aspiring fund managers understand how to run a syndicate. It also helps them determine if it is the right time to start a fund. The endgame here isn’t simply to raise money but to build trust. Join now to start a successful journey towards creating your first fund! 

FAQs

What is the biggest mistake first-time fund managers make?

The biggest mistake is launching a fund before earning investor trust. First-time managers often assume credibility comes after raising capital, but investors back proof of judgment, consistency, and track record, not just potential.

Why should emerging managers start with syndicates instead of a fund?

Syndicates are simpler to structure and operate. They let managers deploy capital deal by deal, build a public track record, learn investor communication, and refine decision-making before managing a full fund.

How can first-time managers avoid poor portfolio construction?

Avoid overconcentration and diversify across sectors, stages, and time horizons. Understand the power law in venture returns and allocate reserves for high-conviction investments to maximize upside while managing risk.

What operational mistakes do new fund managers commonly make?

Many treat operations as secondary, ignoring legal, compliance, data tracking, reporting, and documentation. Weak operations slow decision-making and erode LP trust, even if deal selection is strong.

How does Angel School’s Syndicate Blueprint program help first-time fund managers?

The program guides emerging managers in legally structuring syndicates, raising deal-by-deal capital, managing investor expectations, and building credibility, providing a structured learning path before launching a fund.